NHS Choices criticised over out of date, utterly dishonest, trite and patronising information
NHS Choices the Department of Health’s new £14 million "flagship" website contains GP practice information which in some cases is at much as six years out of date, Health Direct and EHI Primary Care has learnt.
Doctors claim the new multimillion Pound NHS Choices website, developed by Dr Foster Intelligence together with LBi and Sapient, contains incorrect information on GP surgeries including inaccurate opening hours, out-of-date information about partners and errors on practice staff and clinic timings.
At the same time listings of primary care trusts, mental health trusts and strategic health authorities have become much more difficult to find on NHS Choices compared with the old nhs.uk site, according to NHS staff.
The new chairman of the BMA, east Yorkshire GP Dr Hamish Meldrum, this week also criticised the site’s ‘health profile calculator’ which enables individuals to identify the top five conditions they would be most likely to be hospitalised for by putting in their sex, gender and postcode.
He told the BBC such general information would not help people but may cause information overload for patients and create additional anxiety.
He added: “ We all share the desire for patients and the public to be as well informed as possible but this is gimmicky and over simplistic and may cause unnecessary worries.”
Dr Trefor Roscoe, a GP in Sheffield, said the public were in danger of being “grossly misled” by the information on GP surgeries on the NHS Choices website. He told EHI primary Care: “According to the site we still open on Saturday morning which we last did about six years ago.”
A check on the information contained on ten surgeries around the country by EHI Primary Care discovered that at least a third contained errors such as out-of-date opening times or partner listings.
Dr Mary Hawking, a GP in Bedfordshire, said she had complained about inaccurate information on the old nhs.uk site and that although she felt the new NHS Choices site provided some additional information there were errors, including a map of her home town which she claims is at least six years out-of-date.
She added: “The information on GPs is still inaccurate: it doesn't list clinics, opening hours are inaccurate, most have no facilities or clinics listed, and the list of staff is grossly out of date: in other words I suspect this was taken, unchecked, from NHS England UK.”
From:
http://www.ehiprimarycare.com/news/item.cfm?ID=2838
When the Department of Health launched the NHS Choices website on 25 Jun 07 in NHS Choices labour wastes £14 million on another useless website Health Direct questioned the logic for the site.
Patients are being asked to rate and comment on another NHS services website launched which they launched last week. The Department of Health is ludicrosly comparing the NHS Choices site to tripadvisor.com, which publishes travellers' holiday reviews.
Heath Direct notes that the Blog Doctors goes further. NHS Choices is described as thus: I have just spent ten minutes looking around NHS Choices and, as you would expect, I hate it. It is utterly dishonest. The last ten years has been about removing patient choice, not increasing it.
The lifestyle advice the site gives is trite and patronising, and at times downright offensive.
http://nhsblogdoc.blogspot.com/2007/06/girls-just-arent-turned-on-by-man-boobs.html
Doctors claim the new multimillion Pound NHS Choices website, developed by Dr Foster Intelligence together with LBi and Sapient, contains incorrect information on GP surgeries including inaccurate opening hours, out-of-date information about partners and errors on practice staff and clinic timings.
At the same time listings of primary care trusts, mental health trusts and strategic health authorities have become much more difficult to find on NHS Choices compared with the old nhs.uk site, according to NHS staff.
The new chairman of the BMA, east Yorkshire GP Dr Hamish Meldrum, this week also criticised the site’s ‘health profile calculator’ which enables individuals to identify the top five conditions they would be most likely to be hospitalised for by putting in their sex, gender and postcode.
He told the BBC such general information would not help people but may cause information overload for patients and create additional anxiety.
He added: “ We all share the desire for patients and the public to be as well informed as possible but this is gimmicky and over simplistic and may cause unnecessary worries.”
Dr Trefor Roscoe, a GP in Sheffield, said the public were in danger of being “grossly misled” by the information on GP surgeries on the NHS Choices website. He told EHI primary Care: “According to the site we still open on Saturday morning which we last did about six years ago.”
A check on the information contained on ten surgeries around the country by EHI Primary Care discovered that at least a third contained errors such as out-of-date opening times or partner listings.
Dr Mary Hawking, a GP in Bedfordshire, said she had complained about inaccurate information on the old nhs.uk site and that although she felt the new NHS Choices site provided some additional information there were errors, including a map of her home town which she claims is at least six years out-of-date.
She added: “The information on GPs is still inaccurate: it doesn't list clinics, opening hours are inaccurate, most have no facilities or clinics listed, and the list of staff is grossly out of date: in other words I suspect this was taken, unchecked, from NHS England UK.”
From:
http://www.ehiprimarycare.com/news/item.cfm?ID=2838
When the Department of Health launched the NHS Choices website on 25 Jun 07 in NHS Choices labour wastes £14 million on another useless website Health Direct questioned the logic for the site.
Patients are being asked to rate and comment on another NHS services website launched which they launched last week. The Department of Health is ludicrosly comparing the NHS Choices site to tripadvisor.com, which publishes travellers' holiday reviews.
Heath Direct notes that the Blog Doctors goes further. NHS Choices is described as thus: I have just spent ten minutes looking around NHS Choices and, as you would expect, I hate it. It is utterly dishonest. The last ten years has been about removing patient choice, not increasing it.
The lifestyle advice the site gives is trite and patronising, and at times downright offensive.
http://nhsblogdoc.blogspot.com/2007/06/girls-just-arent-turned-on-by-man-boobs.html
Labels: health-direct, labour-liars, Labour-waste, nhs-choices
posted by Dr Search- Principal Consultant at the Search Clinic at
9:19 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home